Far Rockaway: Abandoned Bungalows


June 17, 2009 -

Far Rockaway, on the eastern edge of Queens, was once a flourishing summer community. Today, its landscape is like the half-abandoned city of Buffalo, with vast empty lots and a large number of abandoned homes. In 2008, according to the NY Times, the Far Rockaway's city council representative called his district "ground zero" of the subprime mortgage crisis.

Up until the 1970's, the streets of Far Rockaway were lined with hundreds of summer bungalows. Only a few of these cottages remain. Some are now year-round homes. Many have been abandoned, sealed off and covered in gang graffiti. According to neighbors, empty bungalows have been used to stage illegal dogfights. Others are used as makeshift kennels for fighting dogs. One group of 16 bungalows has been taken over by squatters from El Salvador, according to NY Post reporter Sarah Ryley: "The shacks are in bad shape, lacking water, heat and electricity. But the few that are habitable have been turned into adequate shelters, complete with front porches, buckets to collect rainwater, and small courtyard gardens seeded with jalapeno peppers and tomatoes." (Three photos from this series were first published with that article: Squatter Explosion)

Salvadoran Squatter's Home and Garden

80 years ago, Far Rockaway was "the summer getaway of A-List actors," according to the NY Times, which also reports that "in 1929, Groucho Marx owned 24 [bungalows] as an investment." However, "air-conditioning and air travel spelled the end of Far Rockaway’s heyday, and half a century later it hit rock bottom, with high crime, [and] wrongheaded urban-renewal schemes." The Rockaways' "tortured development history," according to City Limits, created a neighborhood where "in place of the empty lots and dilapidated homes, speculative developers built condos and apartments.... almost all of the new homes never sold. Today they are not occupied by homeowners, but by subsidized tenants with limited disposable income..." The NY Post reported in May 2009 that "of the 126 two- and three-family homes built in the neighborhood between 2004 and 2006, at least 76 percent have been foreclosed on or are currently in some stage of foreclosure."

For Sale: Fire Damaged Apartment Complex

The future is uncertain for the remaining bungalows of Far Rockaway. Some are slated for demolition by developers. Others are collapsing under the weight of abandonment. A few that are in good shape are part of The Beachside Bungalow Preservation Association
.

The following photos document the last of the abandoned bungalows:


Bungalow Complex Courtyard


Courtyard, Arch and Bungalows


Bungalow Kennel: A Fighting Dog Named Menace


Abandoned Bungalow


Bungalows and Development


Cage and Bungalow Ruins


Squatter's Home


Squatter's Porch


Hammock and Fireplace


Drying Clothes


Overgrown Bungalow Ruins


Empty Bungalow: Wall Paper


Living Room Ruins


Bathroom Window


Kitchen


Bungalow and Garden

29 comments:

amgphoto said...

Great work, Nathan.

R. Richard Hobbs said...

Just worked on a commercial still shoot in Far Rockaway along the beach - while location scouting in preproduction was looking for the bungalows - I had been out there maybe 10 - 12 years ago and there were many then - if a bit gone to seed... still, they had a certain charm. This time out there were lots of condos / townhouses- built and under construction - you found more bungalows than I saw - good job :)

Conrad said...

Great photos as always!

....oldgrumpymark.... said...

amazing work.

Lynn said...

oh thats funny, the real deal recently did a story of my photos, basically the exact same thing...

http://therealdeal.com/newyork/articles/development-destroying-far-rockaway-bungalows

i'm sure you've seen it already though!

Anonymous said...

What more than one person can't find interest and take photos in the same place? Lynn, you're not the first person to take photos there and will not be the last.

Nathan Kensinger said...

Thanks everyone for the comments!

Richard - There just aren't that many bungalows left! It'd be hard to stage a summertime scene down there with the remaining bungalows...

To Lynn - Thanks for posting a link to your photos. It's good to see that The Rockways are getting some attention, whether through my photos being published in the NY Post or your photos being on the Real Deal.

There is a substantial difference between what you photographed and what I photographed... and the next photographer who goes to the Rockaways will no doubt have their own the unique experience. While your photos are focused on bungalow exteriors and streets, the majority of my photographs are focused on the squatter community that was first reported in the NY Post, and on the interiors of abandoned bungalows... which is not really "the exact same thing" at all.

creature said...

This is sad. When I was a growing up in the early 70's my family owned one of these bungalows.

Sarah said...

Nathan, these photos are beautiful, and you did an excellent write-up as well. I love all of them, and was pleasantly surprised by the one of the barking dog. Cheers!

Anonymous said...

They should burn them all to the fucking ground and re-wild Far Rockaway. The beaches out there ain't bad.

Anonymous said...

What a shame. What happened in East Rockaway is a prime example of misplaced priorities and poor judgement calls among an urban planning elite with limited forsite. Of course, good old Robert Moses played a role in the demise of the bungalows, too. The decision to put in large scale, high rise housing in East Rockaway ultimately killed the community. There are locations sprinkled around the city where bungalows still exist and have not fallen into neglect like this. But the Rockaways probably had the largest concentration of them. It's unfortunate. Someone with the right skill and promotion skills could have possibly seen the charm in these bungalows decades ago, renovated them and marketed them as an alternative for city residents to expensive summer weekend places in the Hamptons and the Jersey shore. Just try to imagine upper West Siders getting on the A train on summer weekends to head to their rentals at the shore. Hey, one can dream. Go ahead and laugh. No one ever imagined the High Line would one day be a beautiful park.

Brenda from Flatbush said...

what a great series, and what a sad reality. Another failure of imagination along our city beachfront...

sassacyprigo said...

What a fuckin waist when families are homeless. And even those not down and out, it seems folks, somebodies would have loved to lives here and make these buildings homes. How does this happen...property just being abandoned, especially near the beach? I thought that meant prime real estate? Thanks for the photos

a said...

great photos ... so is anyone doing anything about the illegal dogfighting? has bloomberg/aspca seen these photos?

Anonymous said...

Great Work,
I lived there(Rockaway-Far Rockaway) as a boy and had many friends who "summered" in those homes.They were everywhere until the city razed them for urban renewal. Nothing changes

Anonymous said...

there is a MAJOR gang problem in these areas, and the blight associated with the area has to do with the lack of work of any kind down there and a monumental commute to anywhere.

Don't underestimate the beaches down there thouhgh, they are beautiful, spacious and great for surfing.

Jill said...

A few years back we considered buying one of the cottages at Rockaway. I contacted several real estate brokers and looked at a couple that were for sale, but the prices seemed really really high, higher than you'd think, and over the one year period that we considered doing this, the asking prices doubled. Our lower bids were snickered at by the brokers - they never even let us get to an actual offer stage.

It would seem, looking at these photos, that nobody bought them who cared about them. They were nice little houses, mostly needing electrical and plumbing work, sitting right at a beautiful beach.

Anonymous said...

Nathan,

You post the death, here is the life. My wife was from the community, she attended FRHS, hanged on the beach and grw up in those bungalows.

Imagine this is pics the people to whom lived there, such social destruction took place.

http://im1.shutterfly.com/media/47b7cc27b3127ccec299459df13100000010O00AauG7hk1Yt2IPbz4C/cC/f%3D0/ps%3D50/r%3D0/rx%3D550/ry%3D400/



http://im1.shutterfly.com/media/47b7cc27b3127ccec29887ad501c00000010O00AauG7hk1Yt2IPbz4C/cC/f%3D0/ps%3D50/r%3D0/rx%3D720/ry%3D480/

This is what is left, your photo's

What was ours and other bungalows was approx 100 ft from the corner on 35th. The only thing that is left is lonely broken sidewalks that slowly nature is taking back.

It was done by 1985, the neighborhood was too dangerous in which on the hot August morning was being razed to the ground. It was time to leave.

If anybody here in Brooklyn/Queens on August 19, you have an open invite to our annual homage to lay a rose to what was our bungalow and lunch thereafter on the beach.

Why who knows may still find a trinket or two there. The last time found a piece of a cup that was in our kitchen cabinet as the bulldozer flattened our birthright home.

You may ask why is not there anything built on the prized land (beachfront) in NYC. A rabbi a couple of years ago was enjoying the day there on the beach and he felt so much sadness and misery. This must be hallowed ground and ordered his family to leave immediately. There is many that state it is haunted, on a lonely night you still can hear the families.

We have found haven in a bungalow on Point Pleasant beach, refugees always dreaming of returning one day.

Our home now.

http://im1.shutterfly.com/media/47b8cc10b3127ccec5aafd8210fa00000040O00AauG7hk1Yt2IPbz4C/cC/f%3D0/ps%3D50/r%3D0/rx%3D550/ry%3D400/

My wife, and sandbar on 89th in FR

http://im1.shutterfly.com/media/47b9dc37b3127ccec6347c0b39e800000040O00AauG7hk1Yt2IPbz4C/cC/f%3D0/ps%3D50/r%3D0/rx%3D550/ry%3D400/

If you ever want to hear the story email: reidqa@hotmail.com

Bhavesh Chhatbar said...

Quite saddening actually

Bedse Caves

Jenny said...

This is a great series of photos, but I must ask - have you been to Buffalo? Or have you just heard that the population is declining and there are lots of abandoned/foreclosed houses? Buffalo has a lot of problems, but I would not compare the ruins of Far Rockaway that you photograph here to the entire city of Buffalo, of nearly 300,000 people, and plenty of lovely neighborhoods!

Anonymous said...

These interior photos are bleak and quiet, yet so rich - and totally mesmerizing. What an unexpected pleasure to see your work. I'm only sorry about what is true of the subject matter.

Jeanne said...

While these photos do tell of a sad history. There are communities of bungalows in Rockaway now that are vibrant and alive. I won't say where, because that would ruin it for us.
Let those who go to the hamptons keep on driving. They don't know what they are missing. These beaches are the nicest on the Eastern shoreline. While the lifestyle may not be for everyone, but is getting back to it's roots. Bungalow communities for families to get out of the city heat, and enjoy with family and friends.
homelessness, gang activity and even dog fighting happen all throughout New York. people from outside only see the "dangers" lurking. Which is the very thing that keeps things quiet and enjoyable there. Once that ends it will be gentrified and be just an other beach town......

Anonymous said...

Jeannie,

The destruction occurred at the edgemere section, at 35 st and spread outward. I am certain you know nothing exists there not a bungalow not even the strip malls.

Your bungs are safe and no doubt loved.

ReneeGKC said...

Brutally great shots, Nathan.

In the early 1950's, I summered with Grandma at Beach 69th St., while Grandpa commuted out from the Bronx on weekends. Beach baby grew up loving the Boardwalk, over and under.

You're breaking my heart. R.I.P.

sevensixfive said...

Thanks so much for these photos and the stories, Nathan.

Anonymous said...

My grandmother purchased a large bungelow on Beach 46th Street around 1920 - it was in the family for many years and was our summer home up until the early 70's. I cannot begin to tell you how sublime a lifestyle Rockaway Beach really was. Beaches were clean and gorgeous during the day, neighborhoods showed enormous pride of ownership with colorful summer gardens, and the boardwalk was THE PLACE to go and be seen at night (great place to meet guys ala One Summer Night & There's a Moon Out Tonight). Then...came the squatters. First, year-round neighbors would call us frantically to tell us our home had been broken into (despite boarding it up for the winter). My dad would rush over there to find plumbing ripped out, moulding pulled off the walls, bannisters taken down, appliances ripped out. Later, there would be human feces on the floor and they'd used the kitchen floor as a base for their bonfires. It just about destroyed us! Eventually, they wound up burning the house to the ground. Fifty plus years of precious memories. What I will never understand...if they wanted a place to live WHY did they have to destroy it (and, by the way, every single house on the block, too?!) Probably among the saddest things that ever happened to me on a personal level. Thanks for sharing the pictures, though. As I explained to my daughter...as much as it hurts to see them, it they are still a small vestige of my past that valadates my memories.

eternalsunshine said...

Wow, so great to have stumbled onto your blog today! I just went to Far Rockaway for the first time, via bike and took pics, a couple "abandoned" shots near in Fort Tilden.

Where are the bungalows you shot? I was mostly around the Seaside area/boardwalk and then west all the way down to Breezy Point. I'm guessing these must be east of the Veterans Memorial Bridge?

Anonymous said...

Congrats. When I tried doing photos near Hammel's Wye, the locals threatened to loose the dogs on me if I took any photos.

Did you find the old courthouse out on the NW shore?

Anonymous said...

You were in wrong locale, the destruction took place along the ocean edgemere etc.